'It's going to be difficult': Legal analyst weighs in on Richard Glossip retrial

News 9 legal analyst Irven Box said this would be the oldest case he has ever seen retried, which leaves many questions for how prosecutors could present decades old evidence to a new jury.

Wednesday, February 26th 2025, 11:20 pm

By: Matt McCabe


-

A Supreme Court decision to overturn the conviction of Richard Glossip in a 1997 murder case does not leave a clear path forward for prosecutors.

The decision allows an opportunity for prosecutors to try Glossip a third time.

News 9 legal analyst Irven Box said there's challenges in the road ahead.

Q: What makes trying the case again difficult?

A: Prosecutors, in a sense, travel back in time to make a case for a crime that happened so long ago, Box explained.

"It's going to be difficult to reconstruct the case to get together the evidence, the witnesses," he said.

Governor Stitt seemed to agree, as he told reporters in a news conference on Wednesday, "It's hard to find witnesses and things from 25 years ago."

READ MORE: Richard Glossip Case: Full timeline of his 27 years on death row

Q: What happens to the evidence?

A: Box said, when many years pass, evidence sometimes loses its quality. Especially cases that pre-date digital litigation files, and digital cameras.

"There is evidence loss," Box said, speaking in general about cases as they age. "There's things that are misplaced. Then, as far as if there's DNA evidence of things that have not been tested, we're talking about a time in between, really, the scientific process, and keeping up with the DNA and doing all that. This was before that. So, it's going to be a difficult thing for a prosecutor to come back in and go through all that evidence."

READ MORE: Death penalty opponents react to Supreme Court decision in Glossip case

Oklahoma County's District Attorney has not yet made any assurances about if and how the case would be retried. However, there are indications Attorney General Gentner Drummond will be heavily involved in the effort. DA Vicki Behenna said in a statement on Tuesday that she and Drummond had already started a conversation on "next steps."

READ MORE: Gentner Drummond applauds Supreme Court's decision to vacate Richard Glossip's conviction in press conference

Matt McCabe

Matt McCabe joined the News 9 team in May of 2023 as a Multimedia Journalist. 

logo

Get The Daily Update!

Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox!

More Like This

February 26th, 2025

March 23rd, 2025

March 23rd, 2025

March 23rd, 2025

Top Headlines

March 23rd, 2025

March 23rd, 2025

March 23rd, 2025

March 23rd, 2025